Bill’s Cash Quote Reality Check: A $4,000 Job for $2,000?
Updated: 4 days ago
By Bryce Allomes | Allomes Accounting | Newcastle, Lake Macquarie & Maitland
Bill has quoted Sarah $4,000 for a decking and pergola job. Sarah has a suggestion: “What if I pay cash? Can you do it for $2,000?”
Bill’s reply: “Sure. Which half of the job don’t you want done?”
It is a joke many tradies will recognise. The payment method has changed, but the timber, hours on site, fuel and tools have not suddenly become half price.
The quote covers more than the time on site
A customer sees the finished job. The business has to cover everything needed to deliver it: materials and consumables, labour, supplier runs, travel, tools and maintenance, insurance, vehicles, quoting, administration and a share of ongoing overheads.
There also needs to be room for the unexpected: a return visit, a damaged fitting or extra time solving a problem. A quote that only recovers the obvious expenses can leave the business carrying the rest.
A 50% discount can turn a paid job into a loss
Here is a separate, simplified example, using amounts excluding GST. A job is priced at $4,000 and its direct costs plus allocated overheads total $3,200. That leaves $800 before income tax and any costs not included in the estimate.
Accepting $2,000 for the same scope does not leave $400. With the costs still at $3,200, the job produces a $1,200 loss. Even a 10% price reduction, from $4,000 to $3,600, halves the original $800 surplus to $400 if costs stay unchanged.
Before agreeing to a discount, work out what remains after the costs of completing the job. The amount coming into the bank is only one part of the decision.
Cash is a payment method
Accepting cash is a normal way to be paid. Business cash receipts still need to be recorded and reported as income, and any applicable GST obligations still apply. Paying cash does not make the job tax-free.
The comic’s point is that cash does not remove the costs or obligations attached to the work. It does not mean every tax amount stays identical when the price changes.
Prompt payment can have value. A genuine discount may make commercial sense where it reflects an actual saving or another benefit to the business. Put the agreed price, payment terms and scope in writing and keep the appropriate invoice and payment records.
If the budget changes, discuss the scope
You can keep the conversation friendly without agreeing to the same job for half the price. Try: “The quote covers the materials, labour and costs of completing that scope. If your budget is $2,000, let’s look at what we can change.”
That might mean a smaller area, a different material, fewer features or splitting the project into stages. Check the revised costs before offering a new price, and document the revised scope so everyone knows what is included.
Over to you
What’s the cheekiest cash discount you’ve ever been asked for? Share the request and your best polite comeback — no customer names needed.
And if you were Bill, how would you answer Sarah’s $2,000 offer?
Need a second pair of eyes on your quoting?
Allomes Accounting helps tradies and business owners understand job costs, pricing and cash flow. Contact Bryce on 1300 957 986 or visit allomes.com.au to arrange a 15-minute call.



Comments